The Fantasy Atheist

Most fantasy roleplaying games are set in worlds where the presence of gods is strongly felt. Source materials for these realms often detail times throughout history where the gods have directly interfered with the affairs of mere mortals. It is usually assumed that most characters in these games not only believe in the gods of these worlds, but also worship them to some degree. The most extreme case would be priests and paladins who are only able to tap into magic because of their devotion to a particular god. Fighters and other classes may also worship gods because of superstitious beliefs or just blind faith, but the gods have less of an impact on their activities. It could be said that every character in a fantasy RPG is religious to some extent, but is it possible to play an atheist character in these games?

Denial of the existence of gods is a difficult position to hold in a world where these beings occasionally walk amongst the characters. How can a character be an atheist when they have literally looked upon Bahamut? How much more evidence does one need? The simple answer is the character believes that these beings exist, but that they aren’t actually gods. They are just able to tap into powers that seem to be beyond the reach of normal individuals. Think about it this way; the gap in power between a human wizard and Tiamat is much greater than the gap between a red dragon and Tiamat. Along the same line of thinking the gap in power between a field mouse and a red dragon is much greater than the gap between a human wizard and that same dragon, but field mice don’t generally worship red dragons as gods. An atheist character would simply believe that the power these so-called gods wield is attainable by everyone. It is just a matter of learning how to close the power gap.

So which class would be the most likely to deny that the gods are gods? Clearly the true believers like clerics and paladins are out. Fighters get no benefit from being religious, but they say there are no atheists in fox holes. Thieves are probably too superstitious to not believe in some higher power.  The most likely candidate is the wizard. Wizards don’t receive their magic through divine blessing. The have to learn it and they always want to learn more. They constantly study spell books and lore in an attempt to understand the nature of magic. They perform experiments to create new spells and magical items. Wizards found universities to teach magic and conduct magical research. All of this is in an effort to unlock more and more powerful magical energies. Extremely powerful wizards are often described as trying to unlock the power of the gods. A cleric or a paladin would never dare to believe they could wield as much power as a god since that would be considered blasphemy. Wizards strive for this power because they simply don’t recognize the divinity of these beings.

So now that the argument has been made that wizards can be played as atheists the question is why a player would choose to do so. The easy answer is that it would provide conflict, the kind that makes for an interesting story. Wizards are often played as arrogant and abrasive so playing them as an atheist really just stretches this out a bit. An atheist wizard would have friction with any clerics or paladins and probably even druids. Imagine playing a wizard who mumbles about “superstitious mumbo-jumbo” under his breath every time the cleric prays to gain their spells. This wizard would also be the one to look for rational explanations in situations and see past the machinations and schemes of cults and demagogues. Basically an atheist wizard can be the scientist in the group to complement the muscle, the priest and the rogue.

3 thoughts on “The Fantasy Atheist”

  1. Interesting proposition, Mr. Worst, but I believe you may have left out a significant aspect of religion in your essay. I do like the argument that “the gods are not actually ‘gods’ but merely beings from whom you draw power,” and my mind is already building a world in which that premise creates mystery and conflict. However, a significant part of religion is the afterlife, and that’s where things get tricky. I believe it gets a little harder to be a strict atheist if a life after death provably exists, and the gods have final say as to what happens to you in that life. At that point, it really becomes moot as to whether or not they’re scientifically ‘gods’ or not, as any being that controls your afterlife is worthy of worship. I admit to being rather unfamiliar with most D&D settings, but I believe that the afterlife is often just as conformably real as the gods.

    I don’t mean to write an essay, but I just thought I should mention that any player motivations concerning gods should also take the existence of the afterlife into account. Hope I was thoughtful, look forward to reading more of your work!

    1. That’s a valid point about the afterlife however an atheist wizard would already know of other planes of existence in a fantasy RPG setting. That doesn’t mean that he believes them to be an afterlife. Even dying and ending up on this plane wouldn’t work because the wizard might believe that he had just been transported somewhere else. He would need to have some tangible proof such as seeing his dead grandmother or something.

      1. Technically a powerful spell user could raise/resurrect or reincarnate a dead person and let them live in a comfortable setting but that would not make the spell user a god.

Join the Party